Lawsuit Prompts Retaliation After Deputy Grinds Woman’s Face In Gravel

A young woman that filed a federal lawsuit against Sonoma County, California after a sheriff’s deputy choked her and ground her face in gravel, says prosecutors filed charges against her in retaliation.

Gabrielle Lemos, 19, was celebrating her graduation from Petaluma High School at her family’s home on June 13 when deputy Marcus Holton responded to the scene to investigate a possible domestic violence situation involving her sister.

According to the lawsuit, Lemos’ sister was sitting in a truck with her boyfriend when Holton began questioning the man outside the vehicle and then pulled her out of the passenger’s seat without cause.

In response, the suit claims that Lemos ran up, protested the officers actions, and demanded a female officer be present before Holton shoved her backward and told her no one else was coming.

The federal lawsuit says family members tried to calm the situation and told Lemos to go back in the house, but Holton walked up the driveway, grabbed her from behind and put her in a chokehold.

He then picked Lemos up off the ground and threw her face-first onto the driveway, the lawsuit claims – and “put his knee in the back of [her] head and began grinding her face into the gravel.”

“Deputy Holton yelled ‘Stop resisting!’… as blood pooled on the ground under [Lemos’] face… despite her screams and her family’s pleas to stop,” the lawsuit says.

Lemos was then handcuffed and arrested on suspicion of resisting arrest and battery on a peace officer before being transported to a hospital to treat her injuries.

Sonoma County prosecutors declined to charge Lemos in the case following three court appearances, and in September, reportedly told her that charges had been rejected for filing.

On November 13 however – the day after she filed the federal excessive-force lawsuit against the county, Holton, and the sheriffs office – prosecutors charged her with one misdemeanor count of resisting arrest.

The decision is important because Lemos cannot proceed with her civil action while she has a pending charge. Her attorney, Izaak Schwaiger, called the move “unethical” and “a desperation play” made in direct response to the lawsuit.

“There’s no other possible reason,” he said, having now filed a vindictive prosecution claim against the county in Superior Court. “They had to reverse-engineer some justification.”

Sonoma County District Attorney Jill Ravitch said the retaliation allegation is “baseless,” and claimed that her office made the decision to charge Lemos in early October, not after she filed the suit.

CLICK banner to get AWESOME COPBLOCK GEAR!
CLICK banner to get AWESOME COPBLOCK GEAR!

Last week, Sonoma County Superior Court Judge Gary Medvigy began hearing arguments in the vindictive prosecution claim and prosecutors tried to derail the hearing by saying “work-product privilege” would be violated if they were forced to testify.

Medvigy said however that he was “going to pierce the privilege” and make them testify under subpoena for why they charged Lemos when they did.

He said the timing of prosecutors’ actions can’t be ignored and scheduled an evidence hearing before a three-judge panel on April 13 – a decision that the district attorney’s office is now appealing.

Originally published at Police State Daily.

EPN2

CHALLENGE COIN LOT SET OF 10 DIFFERENT MILITARY POLICE FIRE SEALS RANGER SPECIAL picture

CHALLENGE COIN LOT SET OF 10 DIFFERENT MILITARY POLICE FIRE SEALS RANGER SPECIAL

$27.99



 Ford Crown Victoria

 Ford Crown Victoria "Police Interceptor" keychains

$15.00



Anchorage Police Department Police Officer 100 years  Police Challenge coin  picture

Anchorage Police Department Police Officer 100 years Police Challenge coin

$7.50



circa 1954 NOS vintage handcuffs still on orginal display cardboard police picture

circa 1954 NOS vintage handcuffs still on orginal display cardboard police

$24.00



Police Patches /You Pick/listed by city/town picture

Police Patches /You Pick/listed by city/town

$6.00



BEAVER VALLEY POLICE SWAT   SERT  ERT   NOVELTY picture

BEAVER VALLEY POLICE SWAT SERT ERT NOVELTY

$6.00



Vintage 8

Vintage 8" x 11" Black & White PHOTO ENGLAND Black Police Officers 1961 HENDON

$29.99



California Highway Patrol CHP Police Womens Girls Gray T-Shirt, NWT Size Small picture

California Highway Patrol CHP Police Womens Girls Gray T-Shirt, NWT Size Small

$13.95



HENDERSON Police Patch - SUPER RARE picture

HENDERSON Police Patch - SUPER RARE

$8.99



Master at Arms (Ships Police) Rating Patch & Gold Badge, 1st Class picture

Master at Arms (Ships Police) Rating Patch & Gold Badge, 1st Class

$60.00



Asa J

is a staff writer that works primarily as an independent advertising consultant employing grass roots strategies to raise awareness about businesses in their local communities. He holds a Bachelors of Communications/Advertising Degree from Appalachian State University. He is Founder of Police State Daily. His work has been referenced in places like The Washington Post and Esquire Magazine. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- If you enjoy Asa's work at CopBlock.org, please consider tipping him Via PayPal or donating $1/month to the CopBlock Network. You can also purchase awesome CopBlock.org Gear from the store.