$780K Settlement After Ohio Cop Trying To Shoot Dog Hits 4-Year-Old Girl

A lawsuit filed by the parents of a 4-year-old girl who was accidentally shot in the thigh by an Ohio cop aiming for a dog, will be settled for $780,000.

Columbus police officer Jonathan Thomas was trying to shoot the family’s dog in June 2015 after he responded to Chandler Drive in Whitehall to talk with a person who had been injured during a hit-and-run incident.

Thomas was walking back from his patrol car when someone called out to him that a woman, Andrea Ellis, had cut herself. What happened next would result in the woman’s 4-year-old daughter Ava being shot in the right leg.

“As the door was open there were children [in the house] and as Thomas went to the house, a dog approached him and the dog ran away,” Columbus City Attorney Richard C. Pfeiffer Jr. said.

As “a second dog came and the officer felt threatened… he took out his revolver and shot at the dog,” Pfeiffer continued. Instead of hitting the animal however, Thomas hit 4-year-old Ava. The 40-pound bulldog mix was not injured and neither was the officer.

Ava spent nine days in the hospital and accumulated more than $250,000 in medical bills because of the wound. She suffered scarring and still requires additional surgeries.

“She asked me several times, ‘Mommy, am I gonna die?’” Andrea Ellis said.

Following the incident, an internal probe launched by Columbus police found that Thomas violated procedures about discharging his firearm in the home. Retraining and a short suspension was recommended but the officer is appealing the disciplinary decision.

Predictably, the president of Fraternal Order of Police Capital City Lodge No. 9, Jason Pappas, said Thomas did nothing wrong and had no choice but to fire at the animal.

“This is an unfortunate incident, but the officer was within his right to use force to subdue that dog,” Pappas said. “The dog was presenting a threat to the officer and he was within his right to discharge his firearm.”

On Monday, the Columbus City Council unanimously approved a payment of $780,000 to settle a lawsuit filed by Ava’s parents with zero discussion.

Attorney’s representing the girl were seeking $1.6 million but Pfeiffer said that because the city feared a jury award of much more money, it was decided that it was best to offer the settlement.


1284x key Ford Fleet Key Pentesting Crown Victoria Police Cruiser Taxi picture

1284x key Ford Fleet Key Pentesting Crown Victoria Police Cruiser Taxi

$6.99



2pcs set Tactical Pen Self Defense Police Military Emergency Gear Window Breaker picture

2pcs set Tactical Pen Self Defense Police Military Emergency Gear Window Breaker

$9.99



Police Magnum 1/2oz pepper spray bottom clip Alfa Benetti tactical folder knife picture

Police Magnum 1/2oz pepper spray bottom clip Alfa Benetti tactical folder knife

$10.99



2021 Police Challenge Coin - satirical Chief Wiggum Illinois New York California picture

2021 Police Challenge Coin - satirical Chief Wiggum Illinois New York California

$14.99



ASSISTED POCKET Folding Blade KNIFE Tactical Survival Rescue Outdoor Camping EDC picture

ASSISTED POCKET Folding Blade KNIFE Tactical Survival Rescue Outdoor Camping EDC

$8.99



NEW Washington D.C. Metro

NEW Washington D.C. Metro "Autism Awareness" (3.75" x 5") shoulder police patch

$4.50



Boston Police Regional Intelligence Center Challenge Coin picture

Boston Police Regional Intelligence Center Challenge Coin

$8.00



Two FOP Fraternal Order of Police Bumper Sticker Car Outside Window Decal 3” picture

Two FOP Fraternal Order of Police Bumper Sticker Car Outside Window Decal 3”

$13.50



8

8" NEW POLICE Rescue Spring Assisted Open Tactical Folding Pocket Knife Grey

$13.95



Dallas Police Department K-9 Challenge Coin.  2

Dallas Police Department K-9 Challenge Coin. 2" 71

$15.99



Asa J

works primarily as an independent advertising consultant employing grass roots strategies to raise awareness about businesses in their local communities. He has an Associates of Arts Degree and is currently pursuing a Bachelors of Communications/Advertising Degree at Appalachian State University. He is Founder of Police State Daily. His work has been referenced in places like The Washington Post and Esquire Magazine. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- If you enjoy Asa's work at CopBlock.org, please consider tipping him Via PayPal or donating $1/month to the CopBlock Network. You can also purchase awesome CopBlock.org Gear from the store.